|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
more comments |
| "Rubina Sahiba - Have had read your poem on "Margala" Hills.
Perhaps due to its theme and background any greeting would not sound
appropriate but needless to mention you have compiled your deep
sorrow, pain and grief with your own words in amazingly good
manner....However, I have concluded that this setback has changed
not our lives but also the SCENE.. At least me, going fwd. I am not
going to call this Waadee, 'Margala' anymore but 'Karbala'......
Regards"
syed sarwat zoha
|
محترمہ روبینہ فیصل
السلام علیکم
قرطبہ مشاعرہ کا لنک ارسال کرنے کا شکریہ۔ آپکا وہ میناروں والا مضمون
بھی پڑھا۔آپکی نئِ کتاب بھی آن لائں دیکھا، ماشا اللہ آپ بات سے بات
نکالنے کا اچھا فن جانتی ہیں اور اسے بڑی خوبصورتی سے اپنے کالم کا
عنوان بنا لیتی ہیں۔ آپ نے قرطبہ مشاعرہ کے کالم میں جن نکات کی طرف
اشارہ کیا ہے،اس سے میں متفق ہوں۔ یعنی ہم لوگوں کوصرف مشاعرہ ہی نہیں
بلکہ اپنے تمام تر پروگراموں میں، گروہ بندی اور جتھہ بندی سے نکل
کراپنی زبان ،اپنی ثقافت، اپنی تہزیب اور اپنے دین و ایمان کی حفاظت کے
لئے پر خلوص کوششیں کرنی ہونگی۔ تبھی جا کر ہم اپنی قوم کو قعر مزلت سے
نکالنے میں کامیاب ہو سکتے ہیں۔ شاید میں آپ کو بور تو نہیں کر رہا۔
خیر پھر ملینگے اگر خدا لایا۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔
اللہ حافظ
محمد فاروق نسیم
|
Dear Rubina
I've been away from the European scene for more than 4 years, and
have no idea about the recent activities of Urdu-wallas. Your column
on the Barcelona poetry reading was not less than an eye-opener for
me. What I had seen in my 20 years of stay in Europe, was quite the
opposite: an Urdu poet would not stand another Urdu poet, period .
I'm not sure how long ago this miraculous Mushaera took place
because you haven't given any dates, but if it's a recent happening,
then I must congratulate the organizers of this event and request
them to arrange for more events like that.
I saw some of Dr. Taqi Abidi's literary research work when I was in
Virginia this summer, but I have never met the gentleman personally.
Your description paints him as a well groomed, courteous and
honorable person with refined manners and a polished taste for
poetry and literature. Please convey him my regards when you see him
next.
Thanks once again for your continued contact and all the literary
gems that you so generously shower upon me.
yours
Arif Waqar
BBC, Lahore |
My dear rubina
AOA
thanks a lot for ur kindness that u always send ur Colum to me. ur
latest Colum . Mushahera . its excellent the way u explained the
reason of success.
i agree with u 100%.
we r so miser that if ther person weather he is Pakistani we never
appreciate. this is one single reason of our deteriorations .
i salute u & dr abidi as well .
i wish i cold be thier to witness this beautiful gathering.
my new novel ( behshat ka rasta . is published. last month.
when i was in Pakistan .
now i came back Australia .
how can i send this book to u for tabsera ?
i hope u & all ur family is happy & healthy.
ur columns alyas make me cry .
but this is wonder full .
with lot of prayers
ALLAH KRAY ZOR E QALUM AUR ZIADA .
wasalm
Dr . shaugufta naqvi
melbourn .
+61 3 8300442 447 |
Dear Rubina sahiba, I have red your column. It is very
interesting and waiting for the next. I am working with Pakistanlink
in Los Angeles. as Editor Urdu. I would like to publish the report
of Mushara in Qurtaba. I know Dr.Taqi. He is working very hard for
the cause of Urdu. Please send me your stories for publication in
Urdulink.
I would like to tell you something about myself. I am a short story
writer. My five books have been published in Pakistan .Recently a
new book has been published under the titl of " Safad Pather" It
comprises of short stories, a novel and sketches of famous writer,
namely, Ahmad Nadeem Qasmi, Mirza Adeeb, Ahmad Fraz, Qateel Shafi
and Farigh Bokhai. As soon as i receive copies from Pakistan, I will
send it to Aligarh Urdu Club.
With best regards,
Sincerely,
Anwar Khawaja |
|
 |
Madam,
Your write-up on Masjid-i-Qurtaba has made me feel sad.
I visited the Mosque as well as the palace and gardens of Grenada
many years ago but I did not feel sad. I just thought that "we"
built them and then lost them but Muslim Spain was a great
phenomenon.
Two years ago, I visited Seville, the original capital of Muslim
Spain. The great mosque there was converted into the grandest
cathedral in the world. Among other things, it has the tomb of
Christopher Columbus. The Muslims lost Seville and then made Grenada
their new capital.
In a coincidence of history, just when Christian Spain conquered
Cordoba and Grenada, Sultan Mohammad Fatih conquered Constantinople.
The big church there was converted into a mosque. In yet another
twist of history, the Turkish Republic turned Aya Sofia into a
secular historic monument.
History is like a river, it changes course and there is not much you
can do about it.
The number of Muslims in Europe and North America is growing
steadily and that is like history changing course again.
We should look back and then look ahead.
Regards,M Saeed Khalid |
Do not be sorry or sad for qurtaba. It is part of rise and fall
of civilisations. The Qura'n also states changing of people de to
their deeds. Inshallah these places shall revert to that desired
state that ever Muslim misses.
IAS |
Thanks for this article.---I want to tell you that i was
anxiously waiting for this article of yours---Some sentences of it
are of worth to be quoted elsewhere.
I have read a lot of books about Spain in addition to of Nasim
Hijazi , Mustansar Hussain Tarar , Maulana Waheed ud din Khan .Now i
can add this article in that list which i usually quote.Thanks again
MUNIR AHMAD |
| VERY GOOD COLUMN FULL OF EMOTIONS AND INFORMATION. I ALSO VISTED
MASJ E QARTAB AND HAVE THE SAME EMOTIONS I WROTE A TRAVELOGUE OF
SPAIN QURTABA QURTABA, I APPRICAITE YOUR FELLINGS. MAY ALLAH BLESS
YOU. BEST REGARDS QAMAR ALI ABBASI
Qamar A Abbasi
52 25th Street
Troy NY 12180
Email: QamarAbbasi@MSN.com
http://www.QamarAliAbbasi.com
|
Dear Rubina,
thanks for the nice tehreer magar kaun samjhay ga dil kay in abloon
ko jo khood hi phoot tay aur phir kisi nai musafat say peyda ho
jatay hain, yahaan kis ko kahani ki samajh aai hay sab hi andhay
behray aur goungay hain.
Ap canada say yahaan tashreef lein aur ham Germany say nah ja sakay
kaheen tow andha moorrdh ho ga gis ko koi deekhta hi nahi faslay
keysay paat sakain gay jab keh manzil kay wajood ka yaqeen hi nahi
chaal tow rahay hain magar gumgasht e manzil ki tarha jis nay ab
mehz chalna hay manzil ki khooj ya zaroorat rahi hi nahi.
Nizam e program e qartabah bhi tow wohi thha koi kisi mulk peh wah
wah karwanay ko sadarat chahta hay aur koi insaniat aur ilmi sifate
illahi ka qatle aam karta hay aur apni wah wah kay liay door door
say nami girami loogoon ko ikathha kar keh qurb o jawar kay
sachgoyoon ko neechha dikhanay ka intezam karta hay, (NAKAM) behaar
haal sabhi ko apna roll ada karna ahy ham ko islah ki koshish say
kaynat ka nizam qabile fehm banana hay allah ham jeysi haq kay
hasool kay liey tarrpti roohoon ko aamale e kheyr kay rizq say
seyrab karay.
ap kay liay Duago hoon
Tahira Rubab Ilyas
CEO
M/s. Rumedi International Imp & Export
Finkeneck -4,
25462 - Rellingen, Germany. |
DEAR RUBINA BAYTEE,
YOU HAVE WRITTEN SUCH A BEAUTIFUL ARTICLE , SUCH A PAINFUL TRUTH AND
SUCH EMOTIONAL COMMENTS THAT TEARS STARTED ROLLING DOWN FROM MY
EYES. I WAS NOT READING YOUR ARTICLE BUT HAVING A FEELING AS IF I AM
RECITING ALLAMA IQBAL'S POEM "MASJID-E-QURTABA".
CONGRATULATIONS AND KEEP IT UP. BEST REGARDS . SKY
Khaleel Y. Siddiqi |
Rubinaji,
A'dab.Kiya khoob pehloo hai sach mein aur haqeeqaton mein tarasha
hua jiska naqsha aap ney pesh kiya hai aur bari bahaduri aur bareek
beeni key sath isey qalam band kiya hai.Bohot khoob.Aap isey apney
muzmoon key aakhir mein rae dahee key column mein chaspan kar saktee
hain.Allah aapko likhney ki taqat sey aur nawazey.Ameen!
Farida Lakhany |
Rubi Ji:
. Believe me that your pen is powerful and you pick up the
right subjects to discuss.
Qartaba hal ya mazi, is a wonderful kavish and I am grateful
that you have suggested to visit this piece of art as well a
memory of our past splendid history. Now after reading this
article my old desire has resurfaced to pay a visit to this
place which has been remembered and written by many of our
scholars both secular and religious.
Please accept my sincere gratitude for the great effort.
Best,
Safee
==================
Safee U. Chaudhri,PhD
Vineland, NJ 08361
|
|
Dear
Rubina Sahiba:
The
Silent Calls for Prayer from the Church Steeples
(Klisaoun ke darmian Khamosh Azanain) is a nicely written
essay reminding us of the early Muslim history in Europe. We
can reminisce the Islamic golden era of Al-Andalus for its
nostalgic and historic values. When it comes to the study of
history, there are always lessons to be learned or else we
are condemned to relive it. While the history of Moguls in
India is still so fresh in our minds, obviously we have
failed to learn any lessons. Today, as you have pointed out,
the people of Pakistan are re-living the economic, cultural
and political circumstance which was created in India during
17th to 19th century as a precursor to
the British occupation of the whole subcontinent of India.
Alas, some nations refuse to learn lessons from history –
and we are it.
Most of
the Muslim nations today are suffering in the hands of
unscrupulous and deceitful, self appointed leaders. In
reality, they are not leaders, they are compradors who serve
foreign powers for personal, short term gains and end up
creating foreign supremacy over their nations for centuries
to come. The 18th century Indian history is
repeating itself in today’s Pakistan. We can see the living
examples of this in Pakistan, Afghanistan and the oil
Sheikhdoms of the Middle East.
It should
not have been surprising that Pope Benedict had refused to
allow Muslim prayers to be held in the Cordoba Mosque, which
is now a Catholic Cathedral. Times change and so do the
social and cultural conditions. After all, the Cordoba
Mosque was built around an old Christian Church. Today, the
Muslims are not short of mosques or land to build new ones.
They should be mindful of what they have to ensure they
retain what they own today rather than cry for what they had
lost centuries ago. As far as holding the prayers is
concerned, God is omnipresent and ubiquitous, one can pray
to him every where or any where. Before we complain about
the Pope in connection with our claims on the Granada
Mosque, we should review the behavior of our own people in
Pakistan where the mosques and churches are being blown up
with bombs along with the worshipers.
Javed |
|
Dear Rubina:
Although I always admired the beautiful architecture and interior
designs of the Mosque of Cordova, I don't think Muslims had any
right to occupy Spain and colonize it for centuries. The Umayyad
colonizers did not do so for the sake of Islam, but it was just an
empire building process, very similar to what the British, French,
Spanish and Dutch and others did in Asia, Africa and Americas and
Australia. Let's not glorify Muslim occupation of Spain. It has
NOTHING to do with the teachings of the Holy Quran. Let Cordova and
the mosque remain Spanish property.
Have a wonderful day.
Taj Hashmi
Honolulu
|
Allah, Haq Subhanahu wa Taala ... Requires, the Muslims, to ...
"Hold fast, unto, Deen e Islam...
Not, Disintegrate, into Firqahs" ... Groups, Formed on the basis of
Trivial Differences, in Ritual Practices.
Firqahs, "are" the tafreeq, meaning, Schisms, and Divisions ... in
Body Islamique ... In, that the
Tafreeq ... Is in, one Muslim Group's Disagreeing; at times
violently,
with the another, regarding the mode, of the Performance, of ... a
Ritual !
Thus, the In-Fighting, among Muslims, on flimsy differences,
what in essence, are only "Ritualistic Differences" ... These
Ceremonial Differences, have very little to do with Islam
The "Groups based" Differences, and In-Fighting, is essentially
Superficial ... hence فروعات ...
and Farooaat are Differences, in a Ceremonial Ritual's Practice.
Thus, a Firqah ... Is, the Ritual Form, of Practicing Deen e
Islam... The Ritualistic Version, of Islam ...
Its sanction lies in the Fact, that, those Following a Ritual Islam
... readily Allow
Interest in their lives ... saying,
"بھائی مذہب تو انسان کا ذاتی معاملہ ہے ... سود تو دنیاداری کا اہم جز
ہے، جب
وقت آیے گا دیکھا جایے گا ...
Do you suppose, it is correct, for one to declare another, a Kafir,
merely on the basis of
how, one differs from the other in, say ... addressing his Creator.
Syed Hasan Shahid Bukhari
06th May, 2010 |
Salam
Buhat khoob, buhat kam log es tarah sochtay hayn, Dar asal hamara
danashwar munafiq ho chuka hay. es my adeeb bee hayn politicien bhee
garaz kah har woh log jo kisi na kisi jaga pay kuch makam rakhtay
hayn woh sab hee munafiq hayn, hamara hal aysa ho chuka hayn kah jab
bhee bhook lagayee gie hum apney satiyoon ko hee kaha jayeen gayee.
buhat acha likha ap nay. keep it up
sam |
Well written. The solution is that all of us who believe in the
necessity of the unity of the Muslims should start the slogan
'Return to Qura'n' and practice it. Paste it every where preach it
when and where ever appropriate in a subtle way. Say nothing more.
IAS |
"Hi Rubina....AAP K QALAM MAI TALWAAR KEE KAAT HAI....SACH KEE
KARRWAHAT HAI...NAM-NIHAD MUSLIM K DHONG KO AASHIKAAR KIYA HAI....AAP
KEE SOCH BARRI BOLD HAI...AIK OURAT HONE K NAAATE,
bEHARHAAL HAQAAAIQ BOHAT TALKHH HAIN LEKAN IN KO ADMIT KARNE AUR
APNI ISLAH KARNE MAI HE HAMARI FALAH HAI WARNA....HAMARA NAAM BHEE
NAHI HO GA KISI SANAM KHHANE MAI....
NAQAAR KHHANE MAI TOTI KEE AWAAZ KON SUNTA HAI....LEKAN AAP APNI
CAUSE JAARI RAKHHYYE....ALLAH ZAROO SUNE GAA...." |
Dear Ms Rubina
A friend of mine sent me your article on firqas. I found it very
thought provoking. You have called a spade a spade. This is the real
problem and threat facing our country and nation. I hope some other
writers can draw the attention of the masses on this issue,
otherwise it will continue to contaminate us more and more. with
kind regards.
javed iqbal |
| A bold and thoughtful effort. Keep it up. Dennis |
Ruby
you have touched a very sensitive topic very sensible and wisely
I wish and pray that people like yourself are able to create
awareness among us as muslims and as pakistanis,as it is very badly
needed
all the best
Aliya |
assalam o alikum
aap ne molvi ko bura bhala kehnay mein koi kasar nahin utha rakhi
shaed iss ki waja koi zati ikhtilaf ho ya koi aur mein nahin janta.
magar aik baat jo mein aap ki nazar kerna chahta hoon wo ye hai k
kabhi aap k husnband ya children ya father ya brothers ne kisi
dosaray firqay k molvi k peechay namaz perhi hai. har giz nahin
perhi ho gi. asl mein molvi ko hum ne hi strick keya hai. deen aik
hi utra tha magar aap aur mein ne iss mein rakhnay daal deay bus
molvi ko kosna kafi nahin. dosra terrorism ki bat ki aap ne.
pakistan ka prime minister sab se bara terrorist hai bcoz ye
brussels kya kernay gaya tha. lanti ka bacha israel k khilaf nato ko
kehnay gayatha ya nato k sath comprise kernay. iss ka saboot kal ki
speach hai jis mein israel ka zikar to nahin albatta nato se mangi
gae kherait zooror nazar aati hai.
M.IRFAN BUTT
MULTAN PAKISTAN |
 |
Respected Rubina Faisal Saheba
Salamat rahen
Aap ka coulmn firqay kayoon, ghaur say parha , aap kay dil main jo
dard hay , ye bahut say diloon ki awaz hay,magar har shaks
kay gird aik hisar hay magar ab tuta pinjeray say nikalna cahata hay
aap ki tarha aap apna safar jari rakheen aap
yaqeen rakheen bahut say loog aap kay sath hain.
Dheer sari duaoon kay sath
Irshad Hashmi
Germany |
Jawwad Jay commented on your link:
"Rubina jee SALAM ,,,,Yehi tou hmaari qoum ka,
muslim qoum ka sub se barha alamiya hay
k hum firqoun ko mazhab se zyada ehmiyat daitay hain,
kehnay ko tou hum sub firqa parasti k khilaaf hain
magar under hi under, dil hi dil main, hum kisi na kisi
firqay se bhi wabasta rehtay hain,,,,,
kiya ye munafqat nhi hay,,,
MUNAFQAT jo kufr se bhi barha gunah hay,,,,
FIRQA PARASTI jb hi khatam ho gi jb hum
apnay under k MUNAAFIQ ka gala daba daingay,,,,
oar wallah aalam ye waqt kb aaey ga jub
muslim itni himmat walay houngay.
thanx.
|
بہت خوب کالم ہے ۔
اشعار کس خوب صورتی سے جا بجا ٹانکے ہیں۔تحریر کا اثر دونا ہو گیا ہے
ایک بے بضاعت اور بے نوا پڑھنے والی کی طرف سے خراج قبول ہو
جہاں آرا
|
Dear Madam Rubina Faisal
assalam o alaikum
hope you are fine.
Actually this column of yours is written in great haste and in a
time you were extremely emotional. I dont know whom you are
addressing. You are just airing your anger on all sides. Yes. Me
too, among scores of other muslims round the globe, do pray, do pay
zakat and alms, and the like, but I don't think I am burdening
someone with the load of these things as you have given a picture of
yours. Molvis have done a lot bad, and they are done it in the name
of Islam. This is so because they have only Islam with them to sell
out. Rest are selling their commodities. Islam is ever and best sold
by the molvis. But these molvis have never been so powerful unless
the dogs which we have been keeping for our safety would'nt bend to
serve their cause. This is the real curse. Maybe you find enough
courage to jot the real and complete picture. You are excused since
you cannot!! Aap hi kiya, mard e momin k bhi to bachay hotey hen,
mard e mijahid bhi to pait rakhta he.... Anyway
hsm |
yay firqa bandi hamaray zawal ka nazara hay jisay dunya k ahle
danish hamaray mantaqy nateeja k muntazir hain.....yay zamany may
tabah hu nay ka roashan saboot hay....
zahid amin. |
Dear Rubina, Aap nay sirf aif fiqrey mein sari kahani keh di
hay. Quran mein kiya likha hay. Hamara Mulla hamein kiya bata raha
hay.
In Mazhab sab say pehlay apni maan ki god say seekh ta hay. Maa agar
mazhab janti hay. Usnay Quran parh ha hay us ko samjha hay us par
amal kiya hay. Issi tarah Walid ka maam la hay unhon nay yeh sab
kiya hay tab 90% imkan hay keh aisay waldeen ka Bachha firqa parasty
mein nahin paray ga.
Firqa agar Paanch hein to is mein koi haraj nahi hay. Yeh Jama Azhar
Misr kay Manay huway hein.
Shafi Malki Hambli Hanafi Jafri
Is kay baad sari khud parasti aur apni leedri chamka nay wali batein
hein.
Han agar walden paray huway nahi hein tab insan ko haq ki tallash
khud karni paray gi. Beshak Ismlam deen -e- Fitrat hay. Is ka matlab
hay keh har insan peda hotay waqt muslim hoga lekin bara honay par
woh apnay walden ka mazhab
qubul karay ga. Lekin Quran kay mutabiq us ka farz hay keh woh haq
ki talash karay.
Adam Ibrahim Musa Eisa Mohammad yeh sab Muslim thay Allah taala ;ki
taraf say.
Jab insaan science parh ta hay tab usko pata chalta hay key gravity
kiya hay.
Issi tarah agar Quran na parh ha aur na sam jha tab kiya pata chalay
ga keh mazhab kiya hay.
Shoaib |
Rubina Ji
"Khahan mer gaya sala" baut khoob....kash kahee nakhuda mel jaye es
watan ko.
Muskratee rahye aur apne qalam se logoon ko jagane ke koshash jari
rakhain,,,ke insan to koshash ka hee mukalef hai na.
Allah Hafiz
Shabbir Butt
Bahrain |
روبینہ فیصل
تم نیں تین لوگوں کی خطوط تو چھاپ دیے ...
یہ تو بتاو تمہاری اپنی بھی کوئی را ی ہے ؟
یا صرف صحافت پرزندگی گرزانے کا ارادہ ہ ہے
بہار حال ، اب چونکی تم نیں سوالات اور جوابات بھیح ہی دیے ہیں، اور
(bey Farmayad) "بقول شخصے، یہ بات "بے فرماد"
کی زمرے میں آ جاتی ہے لہذا
میں ان سوالات اور جوابات کو، تمھارےہے سوالات اور جوابات تصّور کروں
گا.
اور، جوابات، با وجوہ طوالت، انگریزی میں لکھوں گا
Because, I am not proficient in the Roman script, which, most of the
times, Trans-literates, my Roman,
into a strange version of, Urdu تجوید ... And in correcting it, I
have to waste a lot of time, thus, my resort to,
what I am proficient, at ... Writing on the PC, in English.
Therefore, in future, as a rule, I will be replying to all your long
queries, in English.
so here goes ...
I suggest, the better way to a REQUIRED Understanding, is in your,
first reducing the Subject, into its Specifics.
Meaning, if you want to Know, how the Automobile Works, you should
take it apart, and study its sundry Components;
it takes time, but you learn, and are able to improvise, and make
one suited to your Specs. Otherwise ... you Continue
to Associate the engineered Ashton Martin; DB 5, 6 or 9, with
Hollywood's James Bonds.
Regarding the First Letter...
I think, the gentleman is under the delusion, that "عالم ا ادراک
انکی ذات پر موقوف ہی" ...
Anyway, his حل , of a Red Revolution ... what here, ostensibly,
implies a bloody revolution, is an
outdated concept.
Because, such was only possible, when, Pakistan's population was
around 20 million, a
100 years ago, and a blood bath, was then in the Required Order, of
things, done, by such, as
Communist Adventurers.
It is certainly not applicable, to the present day, Pakistan, with a
population of 180 million.
Because, In a situation, where hundreds of millions of Humans are
involved, a Required Change,
can only be effected, by Changing the State, of the hundreds of
millions of Minds.
Hence, it means, the Change, in the Perception of Reality, by these
vast numbers, and is therefore,
the Correct Solution ... not an Arain's proposed "Surkh, Inqalaab,
or Salaams."
If you carefully read what I write, you will remember, that I had
earlier sent you the definition of "Leadership" ...
But I will repeat it once again:
"In the Islamic Concept, Leadership Means an Accountable
Responsibility"
of the Ruler ... not the bullet proof cars, public adoration and
presidential palaces ... etc. etc.
That, Leaders are born ... not made, at the Harvard, or MIT like
Schools, ... or at our Colleges and Universities.
What these Schools and Universities Produce, are essentially Brand
Mangers.
Thus, a National Leader, cannot, and should not, be equated with, a
Commercial "Brand" Manager.
Its like Mirasis, and the Hera Mandi walay, or the Lohaars or the
Chamaars and the Arains, being Branded,
as the only Castes, as ones, having, the Required Qualities of
Leadership ... For this is how, they are prone to Act,
think and Believe. Because, Nothing else Exists, outside, their
Kouaans .
Why ? Because, the Political Form of Leadership, and Governance, is
an Art Form, and it takes at least 5 Generations, in Power, to
Perfect the Art ... and these Mirasis, and their Generated, do not
have the Art ... But is it not foolish to equate, Singing, Tabla and
Sarangi Nawazi, with Governance ... or Managing the Public Affairs,
in Real Life ?
Have you noted the Symphony Orchestra like Arrangement, in our
Political statements ... Be it the Brass, or the Percussion, or the
Strings and Flutes ... all ... Basically Following, differently, a
Performed Work, of a Composer ?
Whats wrong, in Pakistan, is, that sumandar paar kay Shylocks, and
Cowboys, over the past two hundred years, have, been successful
[with Free Masonry and Money] to Place, these so called, Excellent
... Grand Masters, and Covert Chamchas ... the Khan Bahadurized,
Mirasis and Arains etc. at the helm of of our Political Power, and
later, Calling them, your Excellencies !
Why ? Because, these Mirasis etc., and/or their First or Second or
third or fourth Generations, lack the Required Mettle of Character,
thus, they are easy to Manipulate ... towards the Sumandar Par
Walay's Objectives, than ... the Right Mettled ones, who always
refuse to sell their Zameer: conscience, or, the Watan .
But let me tell you ... I have nothing against the Mirasis etc., as
human beings ... What I abhor, is their, first or Second or third
Generation's, "Importing, and then Mandating, their, inferior
Culture, which is unfit for the Institution, of National
Leadership."
Regarding the Second Letter, referring to "Roshni ki Jhalak ...
Imran Khan ... And why, it is not Reflected in his Team ...
I have to say, "That what, the gentleman from Lala Musa sees, in the
Person of Imran Khan, has more to do with what he wants to Believe,
than Reality."
Imran is good, as far as Cricket, and the Philanthropic Orientation
of his Cause, is concerned... That he should not have gone beyond
these two, as the Purpose of his life ... There are infinite
possibilities in them both, and he should have devoted his energies
to Cricket and Shaukat Khanum Hospital ... instead of Translating
the Turkish Justice Party's Manifesto, into a Movement, he is not
qualified to lead.
But in countries, with a leadership, like the present one in
Pakistan, composed of Mirasis etc., one is easily distracted by
Personal ambition ...
Try to Remember, " روشنی ... Emanates From Truth ... not the Chehras
of Cricketers, or NGOized Philanthropists, or the Khan Bahadur
Progeny, or the Playboys and the Julahas, Lohaars, and Mochis, etc.
turned Milllionaires and Billionaires by Robbing the People and the
Corrupt state. The hedonist Sardars, Jagirdars, the Bank frauds,
Corrupt Bureaucrats, Judges, Mullahs, and Bandits are also a part of
this long list ... Misfits ... but Placed, Rulers " ...
Thus, "Companions of Pakistani Leaders, are the True Reflection, of
their Real Person ... What we see, of them, in the Media, or in
their real life faces, is an optical Illusion; created by makeup,
and at times, by our hopeless Delusions.
It is for these Reasons, that, a Political Change in Pakistan, means
a Change, of names and Faces, they all Speak one Jargon ... They
neither have the Capacity, the Ability or the Intent, to Change the
Reality of the Pakistani's Pathetic Condition, in Pakistan...
Do you Understand ?
Regarding the Pakistani, writing from Saudi Arabia, that " people of
Pakistan, cannot seem to be unable to Unite at a Point" ...
The Fact of the situation, is quite different, than what appears ...
For it is so, because of the Placers Hired, Local Proxies ... well
fed, well placed, and secured ... whose job is to see to it, that
People of Pakistan do not rally and Unite under one Flag ...
And ................................. about the famous, the youngest
Billionaire, the Programmer of face book, I have to say, that first,
he used his head, made the Software, by Applying, his Idea ... Thus,
came up with a web site, which could Serve the New World Disorder
Plan, thus, was Allowed, [like his Fellow Programmers] as Owners, of
Media and the Internet Sites ... by his Establishment...
Tell the boy, "Do not to run away from Pakistan" ... come back home,
do whatever little you can do, face the World's Oppositions, and
singlehandedly build Pakistan's Place on the Internet, do so, for
your Future Generations. That this is what, we are supposed to ...
Syed Hasan Shahid Bukhari
27th May 2010 |
Comment:
:) ye to murghi aur anday wali behez hi ho gai Rubina behen.
Although I have a much smaller intellect to cook up any solution to
our national tragedy, but I do have a small incident to share. It
happened in 2002, in Lahore. I was driving my car home, when a man
came from wrong side, and almost hit me. I pushed hard brakes. He,
while speeding his car off, angrily looked and passed on some curse.
Only one thought hit my mind at that moment, "This man deserve a
Trespasser like Musharraf to be his representative". And then I
realized that majority of us carried this attitude of trespassing,
exploiting whatever is within our power etc. We deserved Musharraf,
as much as we deserve Zardari today.
Yousuf Sahib, as you talked of "red revolution", I wish that you
would have been alive in times of Karl Marx, so that you could have
told him to stop writing Das Kapital in first place.
I think that understanding a problem is a step towards its solution.
So by writing and thus raising awareness about understanding our
problem, we can move closer to solution. But in the end, it is not
the scholars, but each and every person who's living in Pakistan,
holds the key to solution. Let's stop "deserving" Zardari and these
rogue leaders first. Wo "Sala" sahih wala leader khud hi samnay aa
jaiy ga :) |
| aap ka article tu aap k har article ki tarah ba maqsad hay magar
ham nay tu FB ku hi band kar dia hay ......ub na bajay ga bans na
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,.... zahid |
محترمہ روبینہ فیصل صاحبہ
آپ کا کالم بہت اچھا لگا۔ تیسرے برقی خط میں فیصل شہزاد نے چیٹ چینل،آن
لائن گیم سرور کے بارے میں درست لکھا ہے بلکہ کچھ اردو سائٹس بھی ان
میں شامل ہیں۔لیکن اصل مسئلہ یہ ہے کہ ہم لوگ دوسروں کی اصلاح کرنا
چاہتے خود کو راہ_راست پر لانے کا نہیں سوچتے۔ ہم لیڈروں کی اصلاح
چاہتے ہیں جبکہ آللہ تعالی کے فرمان کا مفہوم ہے کہ جیسی قوم ہو گی
ویسے ہی حکمران اس پر مسلط کر دیے جائیں گے اس لیے ہمیں پہلے انفرادی
سطح پر اپنی اصلاح کرنا ہوگی اور نئی نسل کی تعلیم وتربیت اور مرحلہ
وار دیگر مسائل کے حل کیطرف بڑھنا ہو گا۔ مادیت سے روحانیت کی طرف سفر،
اور دنیاوی حکمرانوں کو چھوڑ کر اس حاکم_اعلی کی طورف رجوع۔۔۔
شاہین فصیح ربانی |
Dear Rubina.
1. Masail ka pata hay lekin hal is liye samajh nahi aata keh honesty
nahi hay. jab tak har khandan mein honesty is tarah saryat nahi kar
jati jis tarah insan kay badan mein khoon dorta hay, isi tarah
honesty bhi us kay khoon a lazmi hissa hona zaroori hay. Yeh hum
mein jitni bhi kamzoorian nazar aati hein yeh sab honesty na honay
ki wajah say hein.Saari burai yun ki aik hi wajah disnoesty.
Mein jis honesty ki baat kar raha hoon woh hay insan ka khud kay
saath honest
hona. Is cheese ki hum mein kami hay.
Aap ko surkh inqilab ki hahi balke education ki zaroorat hay. Jab
aik insan apnay saath honest hoga tab hi woh har zavia say apni
bhali kay liye sochay ga. Uski positive soch usko sahi simt mein lay
jaye gi.
Is tarah aik gharana,phir aik mohallah,aik district,aik city aur
pura mulk honesty par gamzan hoga tab hi sab mil kar woh nizam lain
gay jo un sab ki mushtarak soch ka nati ja hoga.
Yeh kaam itna aasan nahi hay. Yeh bilkul Paygambaron wala kaam hay
aur baray sabar say hoga. aik din,aik mah ya aik saal mein nahi
balkey is mein kam az kam pachas saal laq sak tay hein.
Hoesty hi wahid rastay hay. Soch ye.
Shoaib
|
aajkal Rubinajee,bus system hee to nahin hai,bus aawey ka aawa
hee to bigrra hua hai,woh zamana gaya jub chup reh key chehek sakta
thha insaan,lekin aaj sawalon key jawab kiya,khamoshee bhee tol kar
mangtee hai aur khamoshee key zakhm bohot gehrey hotey hain....har
kisi ko leader nahin banaya jaa sakta,albatta zara saa bhee kisi
mein
khof-e-khuda dekhein ya,honesty dekhein,uska jum kar saath dena
chahiye....hamarey yahan selfishness bohot hai,jealousy bohot
hai,system ghaeb hai....lehaza,aapas mein mohobbat aur bhaee chargee
baratna aa jaey to ghanimat janna chahiye.Bus ab har insaan thak
chuka hai,aur thakan mein ghar laut jaana chahiye.....kiya khayal
hai?Phir koee nahin poochega key "SAALA GIA KAHAN?"
WS
Farida Lakhany |
| bohat acha column hai rubina, jhunjhorne wala. kash kisi ko
sharm aaye aur koi naik neeyati aur khaloos se rahbari karne ki
thaan le. is bigre aawe ko koi to sanwarne ki koshish kare, such
keha tum ne kahan mar gaye salay sub. |
Hello Rubina:
What a unique way to promote and endorse Imran Khan; your article "Magar
Sala Gia Kahan" claims to have four questions for your readers, but
in fact these questions are the true answers... I don't know why we
have been searching for the monarch (Leader) to show us the path to
prosperity... we need to learn from the history that Pakistan has
suffered more damage from our leader than the ordinary people.
YES, we have enormous problems in Pakistan, but "are we looking for
the solutions from the right places?" the answer is NO.
The time is coming soon, when I will be sharing a "Peaceful
Contingency Plan" (PCP) to not only the people of Pakistan, but to
all our long lost global cousins, just pray for the global peace.
Where the Imran Khan is concerned, I have contested a National
Assembly election in 1997 with his partnership because I used to
believe in him as the Messiah of our troubles like many of us are
beginning to see in him.. Imran is an honest, sincere, and dedicated
human being, but his leadership can not cure the social ills of our
society.. the answer is somewhere else, just wait....
Thanks.
Habib Khan. |
Rubina Faisal:
All the three letter that you have published tell us the most
horrific situation that has engulfed Pakistan.
I have had interaction with lottttttttttts of educated young
Pakistanis who are the most frustrated lot . That means that our
future leaders are also in a state of complete dismay.
Is there a way out ? Yes. First of all, we , the older generation
needs to make frank and candid confessions . The Pakistan that our
leaders got was not prosperous but it had honest and dedicated
leaders and bureaucrats who shephered the country through its
turbulent years. But gradually the country was high- jacked by "
waderas" with feudal mind-sets. The feudal-mind set is not only
among the landed aristocracy but all over-- bureaucrats , army
people,. industrialists etc. all have feudal mind sets. Our national
assembly constituencies are too big . Only " crore-paties" can run
for elections who spend huge sums and then get into total corruption
from day one to recoup what they have spent.
The ruling elites' popularity has come down to less than 20 % and
yet they continue to rule for their own self interest. Right now,
personal interest is number one , family interests number two, clan
interest number three, provincial interest number four ; the
National Interest is the meagre residual element . Unless we reverse
this order of priorities ; we will continue to race towards the
bottom of the pit.
Who will do that ? Only the youth of the country because they are
the KEY stake holders. They need to take their future in their own
hands -- strive to change the corruption-ridden system ; insist that
the political parties have elections in the parties themselves ;
those who do not have intra-party elections , they should not be
allowed to run for elections /.
In due course of time the genuine leadership ; responsive and
responsible ; will emerge . It is a long , tough road but there are
no short cuts or quick-fixes.
The national reform agenda should continue to be discussed and
discussed vigorously . Solutions will surface only and only if face
up to the challenges and search for solutions that are home grown
and NOT " donor-driven". United we have a chance to survive; devided
we will go down.
Thanks for your efforts to share the feelings of the people who have
been marginalised in the present self-erving system of the elites
for the elites.
With profound regards,
Fateh M . Chaudhri |
Dear Ms. Rubina Faisal,
The anxiety of the youth in Pakistan mirrored in your column is
quite natural. We are the victim of religious extremism, terrorism,
sectarianism, feudalism, militarism, fascism, emotionalism,
illiteracy, poverty, over population,bureaucracy, corruption,
bribery, banditry and brigandage. How such an over burdened nation
can survive? Should we wait for miracles to happen? Are we waiting
for some Messiah? Mr. Bhutto was a visionary and popular leader and
became the victim of the conspiracy of the imperialists. Pakistan
has seen four martial laws. We are an unfortunate nation. Ms.
Benazir was an other intellectual and visionary leader. She also got
killed. Mian Nawaz Sharif had popular mandate but was deposed and
expelled. These civilian leaders mentioned here might not have been
ideal for all. Every body has his own choice and vision so far as
leadership is concerned. But they were the best out of the available
lot. Presently we need civilian leadership. Let the democratic
process continue. It must not halt. If one government goes, let the
other come but by democratic process. No military rule should be
accepted. The only panacea of our social evils lies in education,
social justice, moderation, rationalism and democracy. We should
hope for better future but it needs strenuous struggle. We need
capable , honest and patriotic leadership from middle class.
Besides, last night I was at the residence of Mr. Jafar Naqvi in New
Jersey in a poetry session. I also recited my fresh Urdu poetry. Mr.
Ashfaq Hussain had come from Canada and Mr. Safdar Hamadani from
London. We had a good evening. I am coming to Canada on May 28, 2010
to read out my essay on the book of Syed Athar Razvi. Hope to see
you there.
With warm wishes,
Sincerely yours,
Dr.Maqsood Jafri
Dated: May 23, 2010 |
Asslamo Alaikum.
App ka Artical Perha or Bohat herann howa keh Facebook Bnany wala
Ikk Dil-jala student hea Or woh abb Duniya ka Ammer Tareen Admee ban
chuka hea...
mea yehi samjhta tha k FACE-BOOK kissi bohat barray Software-House
kee malkiyyat hogee.
Yea perh ker mujh ko apna past yadd a gayya keh Jab mea College may
BCS ker raha tha tabb mean nea Apnea ASP Subject mea 100/100 Marks
Liyea
Same like PHP jiss mea Face-book Desigen hoee hea...
OR WEB Designing k Subject mea Jo Web Site mea nay Desigen kee thee
uss per mujh per yeah Ilzam laga diyya tha k yeah tum nea mariket
sea desigen kerwa keh submit kee hea.
Hamra Assal Dushman Hamra System hea. Mea nea Chats Channals Per
Riview kiyya ONLINE Public Games Server per review kiyah. OR
Nateejah nikla Group bandi
Hamari soch ikk jagah per kabhi bhi akthi nahi hoti jo channal ka
admin hota hea woh uss channal ka WADERAH BANNA HOTA HEA usshee k
apnea pasand k log hongea or yeah grops sirf or sirf apass mea
batean karean gay. even k appke salam ka jawab dena bhi gawarah nahi
kertea.
Games Server Per Bhee Admin (WADEERA) Apnea Pasand k logon Rkhea ga
OR Unhi ko Mar-aat sea Nwazea GAA...Baki ko BLOCK ker dea ga. Or
yehi wajah hea keh hamm log bohat peeche hean. Yani Ittfaq nahi hea
jo hamari tarraqi kee sab sea barri kamzori hea.
Or Agar koi Apni Mehnat sea Kuch naam kama bhi leta hea to syasi
Luteary uss ka sattya nass ker detay hean or majbooran woh Pakistan
sea Jan bacha ker bhag jata hea.
Wah Rea FACE-BOOK k Owner kash ham ko bhi tujh jesa azzad Taleemi
Maahol milta achea dost miltea or acha system milta to ham pakistani
bhi kissi sea kam nahi hean... AFSSOS DAR AFSOSS..
Best Regards
Faisal Shahzad
Dammam
Saudi Arabia |
i read your article and i want to answer your questions and i
want to ask some questions.... and i want you to publicize my
question and answers so other people can understand..... but first
you need t understand.....
dekhiye khatoon.... aap nay bhi buhat saray sawal kiye hain, jo is
mulk ka her banda, balkeh har bashaoor bandah pooch raha hay...
keh yeh kab ho ga, kay wo kab ho ga, hamara naujwan aisa kab karay
ga, hamara naujwan vesa kab karay ga... aur ham kab aik nation ban
jayeen gay..... aur aisa aur vesa...
to jawab yeh hay.... yeh us waqt tak naheen ho ga jab aap esay loge
aisay columns likhna naheen chore dain gay.... bus in sab batoon ka
yahi jawab hay
ab mera swal aap jesay logon say yeh hay kay....
Sawal No. 1
kiya kabhi aap may say kisi nay in masayel ka hal bataya hay.....
masayel sab k patah hain... bachay bachay ko pata hain laikin hal
kisi kay paas naheeenn.. Hal kaun day ga.?
Sawal No. 2
Kabhi aap main say kisi nay socha kay hum loge (pakistani) itna kuch
sehnay kay bavjood surkh inqilaab ki taraf quen naheen barhtay.?
Sawal No. 3
Kabhi aap may say kisi nay socha kay hum loge (Pakistani) roze baroz
bad tar hi quen ho ja rahay hain.?
Sawal No. 4
Kabhi aap may say kisi nay socha kay hamaray andar leader peda honay
quen band gaye hain
meray paas aur bhi buhat saray sawal hain
zara in ooper walay savalon ka jawab to dhoondain aur let every one
get these answers.. |
Farhat Perveen commented on your note "facebook ka asal face":
"bohat maloomati article hai, tum ne asik traf to facebook k ijra
aur irteqa ki tareekh likhi hai to dosri traf un logon ko aaina bhi
dikhaia hai jo iska ghalt istenmal kar rahe hain." |
Dear Robina.
Nice article.
Situation is gone from BAD to WORST in Pakistan. We have identity
crises. (We mean Pakistani) It is in my experience that some of our
young people born and raised in the USA or UK etc. are reluctant to
call themselves Pakistani.
Nothing good is coming out of our country. From the President down
to a peon in common office is corrupt, dishonest and immoral .
We were pushing for democracy. Look what we got? Love Irshad |
I have gone through your latest article, “Face book ka asal
face”. It’s really alarming, motivated and informative one. By the
way I have gone though your couple of other columns too, e.g. “Imran
Khan ko mulak badr karma chahye” and “Ab tau tu bik b nahee sakti”,,,
What a beautiful style and impressions they do possess. Please keep
up the good work. I wish you good luck and every success in your
future endeavour.
Best regards,
Chaudhary Rehmat Ali
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia |
-your article "facebook ka asali face " has caught my heart
when u were telling that those people who were victim of loneliness
or those people who were not being heard, i was thinking that u are
talking about me
Indeed now people have got a source of outlet for telling their
inner passions. It ( i must include other internet magazines/forums
too) has helped to reduce tension (including of mine too) which was
cooking in the minds.
This is right that i can write easily in print media of Pakistan
easily but despite that i feel a sort of no security while
expressing myself. In other internet forums i express easily my
thoughts
Merely same comments have been written by me in ur face book
MUNIR AHMAD |
ASA
Dear Rubina Faisal,
umeed hai app khairiat se hon ge....app ka article parha ....aisa
laga jese haqeeqat nasamjhi ka dar khole hamare samne khare hia.
yaqeen manye bohat bohat acha laga......
face book ka jo istemal hamare nojawan nasal ker arhe hia yaqeena
naqabl-e- qabool hia .....
hamari nojawan nasl ke liye sirf flirting kerna or time pass kerna
hi kue zaroori ho gaya hia.?
well and excellent article written by u.....
God bless u more and more
REgards
Shaheen javed
Riyadh |
Salams Rubina..
Your article on Facebook is excellent.. and true to dot. Too much
openness and total lack of privacy is causing a lot of problems on
it. Like every tool.. FB has its pros and cons.. but unfortunately
as is the nature of human beings, we usually find the worse way to
use a tool.
Keep writing!
Farhan |
Qudsia Nadeem Laly commented on your note "facebook
ka asal face":
"rubina,bohat hi sachaiee say aap nay FB ky tammam hawaloon say baat
ki,mujhye yeh keynayen main hamesha fakhar raha ky main pakistani
hoon.orr na janye main yeh dukh kab tak bayaan karti rahoon gi ky
pakistani quoom eak zarkhaiz zehan rakhnye ky bawajuood apni
salahiyatain barbaad kartye hi chalye ja rahye hain!
apnye column or articles main main is baat ka zaroor izhaar karti
hoon ky aaj ki MAA apnye faraiz ba-khuobi ada nahin kar rahin?
jab maa hi ghantoon tv ky samnye baith kar tammam soup drama or
licher filmain daikhyen gi tuo bachye kis trha kisi masbat kaam ki
taraf barrhain gaye?na aaj maa ky pass waqt hay ky wo 2 achi baatain
bachon ko batye?na hi us ko khudh fursat hay ky achi baat kaheen say
lay laye?show shaa,ki is duniya main sub eak duosrye say sabqat
layjanye ki duoor main hain,
Dr zakir naik ky kisi school main dakhlaye ki awaleen shart yeh hay
ky maa/baap satellite chanael's or TV nahin daikha jaye ga,ma siwaye
khbroon ya kisi islami program ky!
or unhi ky mutabiq be-shumaar afrad kuch hi arssa baad aa kar apni
khangi zindagi ky bohat behtar honye ki baat kartye hain?
koi bhi ejaad hamesh masbat pehlye rahi hay,us ka manfi istymaal
hamesh manfi soch rakhnye walye afraad hi karty hain...
rubina eak umda or masbat tehreer per dil say mubrakbad..
salamat rahain..."
|
Afschein Shah commented on your note "facebook ka
asal face.":
"gd wrk Rubina....agreed on most of the points...specially the face
book romance lolz....ppl of all ages wthr married or
unmarried...use it only 4 dat purpose....akhir aurat ko aik dmagh
smajh ke baat q nahi kr sktay mard hazraat :(... "
|
|
Dear
Rubina Sahiba,
Just
read your column, Facebook, I note that you are wishing
to see large business offices in Lahore and Islamabad.
Have you ever thought who is going to provide security
against the TTP terrorists? Supposing you have secured
the premises, how much useful work can be done in those
offices with daily 18 hour power shut down?
The
country has no role models of any kind. The younger
generation can hardly get any inspiration from the
clowns in the parliament. Many of them are sitting there
with fake degrees and some of them don’t even know the
Table of 2. They call themselves the political leaders.
They are political all right but certainly not leaders
of any description.
Some
countries get destroyed in a war, some by natural
disasters, but Pakistan has been bombed by NRO. The NRO
stench is so bad that people can hardly breathe fresh
air. In that stifling atmosphere, sitting in dark,
sweating like hogs because of no electricity, they can
hardly think straight, let alone come up with
revolutionary, technological or scientific ideas.
The
only people who have electricity without interruption
and three square meals a day are the thieves and thugs
sitting in the upper echelons. They have no brains and
certainly no time to think about the national
advancement or development. They are too busy in
manipulating their own version of democracy as much as
possible and obsessed with its
‘husen’
which they never fail to remind us about as part of
their own need for reassurance.
Javed Chaudry |
 |
|
|
